On some methodological problems of terminology in modern music sinology
Abstract
This article raises very relevant issues related to terminological definitions characteristic of scientific works with an oriental orientation. A concrete example is the rapidly developing sphere of musical sinology in recent decades, in which there is a frequent inconsistency or inadequate mixing of terminological designations, in particular, numerous types and forms of national musical and stage art. Having a multi-year history of development, varieties of the traditional musical theater of China, often found in provinces far from the capital, are characterized by an established apparatus of ethnonyms, including the own name of each particular phenomenon. United by the general term shitsyu, they are characterized by canonicity and an integral connection with national art and traditional crafts. With the advent of the capital's jiaju theater, called the Beijing Opera, scientists of the PRC began to designate all types of national traditional theater in a similar way, which gradually led to a terminological collapse that had no place in Russian oriental studies before. The author proposes to carefully comprehend the parameters of the terminological apparatus of the modern musical sinology from the methodological standpoint of the national musical orientalism.
About the Author
M. Yu. DubrovskayaRussian Federation
Marina Yu.Dubrovskaya, D.Sc. (Art Criticism), Professor
Novosibirsk, 630099
References
1. / Anarina, N.G. (1984), YAponskij teatr No [Japanese No Theater], Nauka, Moscow, 213 p. (In Russ.)
2. / Budaeva, T.B. (2011), Muzyka tradicionnogo kitajskogo teatra czinczyuj: Pekinskaya opera: avtoreferat dis. … kand. iskusstvovedeniya: 17.00.02 [Music of traditional Chinese jingju theater: Beijing opera: abstract dis… cand. art history: 17.00.02], Moscow, 28 p. (In Russ.)
3. / Wang, Qiong (2008), Nacional'no-kul'turnye tradicii v vokal'no-scenicheskom iskusstve: na primere pekinskoj muzykal'noj dramy i russkogo opernogo teatra: avtoreferat dis. … kand. iskusstvovedeniya: 24.00.01 [Nationalcultural traditions in vocal and stage art: on the example of Beijing musical drama and the Russian opera house: abstract of dis… cand. art history: 24.00.01], St.Petersburg, 23 p. (In Russ.)
4. / Grishelyova, L.D. (1977), Teatr sovremennoj Yaponii [Theater of Modern Japan], Iskusstvo, Moscow, 19 p. (In Russ.)
5. / Dubrovskaya, M.Yu. (1985), Muzyka v tradicionnom teatre YAponii (Na materiale No i Kabuki). Avtoref. dis. na soisk. uchen. step. kand. iskusstvovedeniya (17.00.02) [Music in traditional theater in Japan (On material by Noh and Kabuki). Autoref. dis. to the nipple. learned. step. cand. art history (17.00.02)], Moscow, 237 p. (In Russ.)
6. / Dubrovskaya, M.Yu. (1989), “Music in traditional theatre in Japan. (on noo and kabuki material)”, Yaponiya: ideologiya, kul'tura, literature [Japan: ideology, culture, literature], Nauka, Moscow, pp. 83–88. (In Russ.)
7. / Dubrovskaya, M.Yu. (1983), Tradicionnoe muzykal'no-scenicheskoe iskusstvo stran Vostoka (na primere muzykal'nogo teatra YAponii) (broshyura), Seriya kul'tury i iskusstva [Traditional musical and stage art of the countries of the East (on the example of the musical theater of Japan) (brochure), Culture and Arts Series], Izd. Obshchestva «Znanie» UzSSR, Tashkent, 24 p. (In Russ.)
8. / Esipova, M.V. (2017), “On the peculiarities of the study of Chinese music in Russia in the XXI century”, Hudozhestvennaya kul'tura [Art culture], no. 3 (21), Available at: https://artculturestudies.sias.ru/2017-3-21/prikladnayakulturologiya/5264.html (Accessed 01 December 2024) (In Russ.)
9. / Mikhailov, J. (2012), “To the problem of the theory of musical and cultural tradition”, Centr «Muzykal'nye kul'tury mira» Moskovskoj gosudarstvennoj konservatorii im. P.I. CHajkovskogo: sajt [Center "Musical Cultures of the World" Moscow State Conservatory. P.I. Tchaikovsky: website], Elektronnaya perepublikaciya [Electronic republication], January 18, Available at: https://worldmusic-msc.livejournal.com/59761.html (Accessed 01 December 2024) (In Russ.)
10. /Mikhailov, D. (1999), “On the possibility and necessity of universal terminology in music”, Voprosy filosofii [Questions of philosophy], no. 9, pp. 106–120. (In Russ.)
11. / Problemy terminologii v muzykal'nyh kul'turah Azii, Afriki i Ameriki: [Sb. nauch. tr.] / Mosk. gos. konservatoriya im. P. I. CHajkovskogo; [Redkol.: Dzh. K.Mihajlov (otv. red.) i dr.] [Problems of terminology in Asian, African and American musical cultures, Sat. scientific. tr./ Mosk. state. conservatory named after P.I. Tchaikovsky; [Editorial: J.K. Mikhailov (resp. ed.), etc.], Moscow,224 p. (In Russ.)
12. / Zhao, Yong (2024), “The legacy of the Chinese composer Wu Zuqiang in the context of the reception of traditions the Russian- Soviet school of composition”, ARTE, no. 2, pp. 34–46. (In Russ.)
13. / Yuzhakova, E.V. (2002), Muzykal'no-hudozhestvennaya sistema tradicionnogo yaponskogo teatra No: avtoreferat dis. … kandidata iskusstvovedeniya: 17.00.02 / Novosib. gos. konservatoriya im. M.I. Glinki [Musical and artistic system of traditional Japanese theater But: abstract dis… candidate of art history: 17.00.02 / M.I. Glinka Novosib. state. conservatory] Novosibirsk, 22 p. (In Russ.)
Review
For citations:
Dubrovskaya M.Yu. On some methodological problems of terminology in modern music sinology. ARTE. 2024;(4):30-37. (In Russ.)